Da Techguy's (no longer backup) Blog

Plot: Lindsey Pepper Bean has a really cool life in the really cool city of Finetime with her really cool friends inside their really cool social media bubble but there something horribly nasty going on in their seemingly perfect world but can the Doctor and Ruby convince her of it and get her out in time?

Writing: There is a reason why the Russell T. Davies Era was so successful and this episode really nails it. He takes a simple recognizable concept (the dangers of living inside of a social media bubble) and turns into into the most colorful (literally the world, the people and the color schemes all cry Barbie Movie) deathtraps that the Doctor has ever confronted. The number of twists and turns this episode (particularly the character of Rickey September) really makes it interesting although the amount of time spent discussing her urine production is weirdly troubling but also is a nod to the idea of the trivial trumping what actually matters in life. All in all a fine effort.

Acting: Ncuti Gatwa has pretty much delivered as the doctor so far and I’ve reached the point where I expect a solid performance (even in meh episodes like the Devil’s Chord) from him and he doesn’t disappoint. A lot is being made of his end scene and I’ll talk about that later but on the whole he delivers an excellent performance. Millie Gibson really grows on you as a companion and although she doesn’t have the big role that she had in last episode (73 Yards) she once again shows that she, like Karen Gilliam is more than just a great set of legs (One of the few episode that don’t show them off). While the main cast is good in the end the entire episode is completely dependent on the performance of Callie Cooke as Lindsey Pepper-Bean who has the almost impossible task of making us want to see her saved while conveying the image of a shallow, scared rich pampered kid to the point of annoyance and beyond. She keeps us locked in and makes it work which makes the moment where she shows her only moment of creative thought and uses it horribly even more impactful. Also kudos to Tom Rhys Harries as the pop star who actually has depth and is in many ways the hands of the Doctor who can’t piece the bubble to do it himself.

Best AND Worst Moment: While everyone is pointing to the end speech here the best and worst moment of this episode comes before that, it’s the best because of the writing and drama of it and the worst because it’s as horrible as it gets. It really defines the episode and the protagonist much more than anything else. I’m not going to say what it is, you’ll have to watch the episode.

Flashback moment: All I could think of just before the final big speech was this moment from Voyage of the Damned when Mr. Copper turns to the 10th Doctor and says: “Of all the people to survive, he’s not the one you would have chosen, is it? But if you could choose, Doctor, if you could decide who lives and who dies… that would make you a monster.” because the irony is that Rickston was much more worthy then Pepper-Bean.

Annoying moment: While it’s a given and clearly established that Lindsey would have been completely incapable of saving any of her fellows you might think that the  Doctor might be doing SOMETHING to get a few of those people just starting to get trapped in.

Big Finish Flashback (s): The monsters reminded me of the Slithergees from the excellent Big Finish Seventh Doctor episode Flip/Flop who were sightless and needed humans to guide them. These creatures were also sightless and needed their prey to literally walk into their mouths. The situation was also analogous to the 6th Doctor Lost Story episode Paradise Five where people are in a trap but don’t know if and finally the 3rd Doctor Story The Transcendence of Ephros where a bunch of people on a dying planet don’t want to be saved.

Doctor without the Doctor Moment: When Rickey September sees what’s happening in the home world and doesn’t share it to keep Lindsey focused on staying alive.

Fooled me completely moment: I presumed that this was basically a farm run by these creatures and was completely surprised to find out who the real “killer” was.

Funniest exchange:

Fifteenth Doctor: Well, what if it can? What if it wants you to walk right into them?
Lundy: Why would it do that?
Fifteenth Doctor: Imagine if that Dot has achieved sentience and then it has to spend all day hovering and listening to you lot chattering away. I’m… I’m not being rude, but I think it’s learnt to hate you.

Plot hole (s): If we are to believe the Doctor’s conclusion above then, given the fate of their homeworld, we must conclude that their entire home world was built by a bunch of annoying shallow useless prats. It would seem unlikely that sad prats would have reached this point of advancement. Furthermore if a bunch of useless prats could build such a world and civilization then it’s possible that despite all odd the bunch of useless prat who survived might actually survive again.

Totally Missing the Conservative Point #1: The fact that the scene where the Doctor pleads with the survivors to let him save them was filmed has caused people who see everything in terms of race decide that the survivors didn’t want to go with the Doctor over his race, in fact the choice to film that first suggests that Davies intended that reaction, but alas there is the little matter of the rest of the story where it is made completely clear that all of these people are the children of the richest of the rich who consider it a great hardship to work 2 hours a day before partying the rest of the time. This screams class, which given England’s social structure and history makes perfect sense. These are the type of useless rich people who their parents would have bought commissions in the army to get rid of them. They see the Doctor as inferior not because of race, but because of class, he’s not one of them. Oddly enough something conservatives have been warning about

Totally Missing the Conservative Point #2 All through the episode the Doctor and Ruby try to save Lindsey by getting her to see what’s outside of the bubble and right now that’s the situation in England where Pro-Terrorist mobs have pretty much been able to take over the streets when they want with the police not enforcing the law on them. This doesn’t even count the various situations of crime were laws go unforced because of the fear of being called racist. The elites and the government inside their bubble refuse to see or acknowledge the danger while British girls and now British Jews are endangered. The allegory of the home world destruction to where England is heading is both telling and completely ignored by apparently all

Totally Missing the Christian Allegory / Conservative Point #3: As a devout Catholic watching the Doctor plead with Lindsey and the other prats to come with him and be saved I couldn’t help but think that this is what Christ and the Church does every single day. The Doctor spends the episode trying to make Lindsey she the world as it really is. Christ does the same. The Doctor does his best to steer Lindsey past the dangers of the world. Christ does the same. In the end the Doctor offers to save all of them, even though he concludes they are shallow and selfish but that doesn’t matter he’ll still save them if they wish. Christ is the same in the end offers us salvation for our sins, regardless of if we deserve it. All we have to do is just take it, but because he wants brothers and sisters rather than slaves he won’t force the choice on us. If we choose to reject that saving hand he will let us go saying Thy will be done. That is as complete an allegory to Christianity as there is and most viewers will completely miss it.

Bottom line: Great episode and more meaningful than the writer might have thought or intended Five stars

Ranking in this season

Well you knew where this was going from the spoiler I gave you:

Episode ranking as I see it (not including specials nor Dot and Bubble which I’ll review this week)

1. Dot and Bubble
2. 73 Yards
3. Boom
4. The Church on Ruby Road
5. Space Babies
6. The Devil’s Chord

I haven’t really done any reviews of the Ncuti Gatwa Doctor Who episodes and I frankly don’t have time to do a full review today but as someone who walked away from the series after Capaldi I want to comment on the season so far today (and I’ll cover this week’s episode later this week) because I think people who are skipping it are missing out.

Point 1: Chibnall clearly isn’t the boss anymore:

I’ve been watching these episodes with my oldest son who unlike me watched all the Chibnall era episodes. As he put it the worst of the episodes to this date is leaps and bounds over the best of the Chibnall era. For me as some who discovered the show in 1976 and watched it regularly since about 78 you can clearly see that the writing and the plotting have improved. Davies being Davies has of course inserted his agenda into the show but that was true and recognizable from the moment the show was revived. The point was can he do so without overwhelming the story. For the most part he has succeeded. These are solid stories, as always some better than others but are clearly recognizable as Doctor Who stories.

Point 2: Gatwa works as the Doctor

I’ve seen plenty of Doctors over the years the two best being hands down Tom Baker and Matt Smith (Tennant is good but VERY over rated). It took a couple of episodes but Gatwa clearly has reached the point where he carries himself as the Doctor. Frankly the early episodes didn’t do him a lot of favors as the first three (The Church at Ruby Road, Space Babies and the Devil’s Chord were, meh) but Boom clearly established him as the Doctor and while 73 yards was a classic Doctor lite story but by that time you clearly saw him as The Doctor. That’s what you really have to do to carry this role, be clearly recognizable as the Doctor while still carrying your own Doctor’s traits. He has pulled that off. I think Davies would have done better to have the regeneration (or bi-generation Trauma) and perhaps that’s reflected in some early weakness (more on that later) but so far so good.

Point 3: Millie Gibson is more than adequate.

It seems to me that they have made Millie Gibson’s Ruby Sunday very strong right at the start which was overcompensating but the character has really worked. The proving ground was 73 yards, the Doctor lite episode. We got to see how traveling with the Doctor (even briefly) has affected her and watched her grow. That to me was the strength of the episode not the lack of Gatwa who as I have already said, had established himself as the Doctor by that time. From what I hear they are already getting ready to dump her and I think this is a mistake as the primary goal of this season is to reestablish the show as something worth watching and Gibson is worth watching

Point 4. The elephants in the (script) room.

A lot of people have written off the series because of the agenda thrown in their faces and we saw plenty of that during the specials and there is agenda here. As I already noted the Davies has been pushing his agenda since day 1 in 2005 but the agenda hasn’t been the boss of the show, at least not yet. As long as the agenda doesn’t get in the way of the actual stories I’m willing to put up with it. There are also those who hate that Davies hasn’t reversed the timeless child stuff, spoiler alert. That isn’t going to happen here and never was in the cards and won’t be until it hurt them financially and with Disney paying the bills that not likely. I simply ignore the references and remember rule #1 The Doctor Lies.

Point 5: Big Finish influences

Those of you who don’t listen to the big finish audios might miss it but there seems to be a ton of big finish influences in this series. Over and over I spot things from audios that I seem to recognize (elder Gods, relatives of the Toymaker for example) . This is not surprising as they have been doing Doctor Who for 26 years and doing it well so it’s natural that you would have some stuff bleeding over even if it’s not all considered canon. Given the quality of the Big Finish work this is a positive rather than a negative. I don’t know if this is deliberate or unconscious but either way it makes the show better.

Point 6: Irony Irony Irony Conservative Messages All Over the Place

One of the things that has been really amusing has been that the Davies crowd is so wrapped up in the agenda that they are missing things that I’m seeing. The latest episode is the best example of this but I’ll save that for my review later this week. Today let’s hit a few today from the prior ones

• In the Space babies episode there is a scene where the intelligent babies suggest there is something wrong with them, but the Doctor reassures them they are good just as they are. While our agenda friends thought they were dunking there actually they dunked on themselves because that is an explicit message against transitioning kids. You are great JUST AS YOU ARE
• In the Devil Chord episode the idea of pushing a Trans character was big, in fact SO excited were they missed what said character was. Or to put it another way: The same guy who was all bent out of shape having a handicapped person as the murderous Davros had no problem at all as a clearly trans character as an evil murderous elder God out to pervert and destroy not just the world but culture and joy.
• In 74 yards I really liked how the Welsh noted how many in England still think of them (shades of Boomtown). More importantly the episode shows how the Doctor changes others in the sense that they see what’s in front of them and act. More on that later this week when we hit Dot and Bubble but that’s constant theme is there.
• And of course in the Church at Ruby Road we celebrate foster parents, the idea that a kid is worthwhile even if said kid is not wanted. That the entire basis for the pro-life movement which I suspect few if any of those involved in product embrace.

Again I’m going to cover Dot and Bubble separately but to sum up. This season of Doctor Who is worth your while not because of the woke stuff so far but despite it. Granted we don’t know if it will turn on a dime but at least to this point, I must say the Doctor is back and he’s been missed.

Episode ranking as I see it (not including specials nor Dot and Bubble which I’ll review this week)

1. 73 Yards ***** Solid episode
2. Boom ****1/2 Nice basic plot
3. The Church on Ruby Road **** OK doctory intro
4. Space Babies **** Not bad but not great
5. The Devil’s Chord ***1/2 Interesting villain but wasted potential with weak resolution & lousy ending.

(spoiler alert the top spot on that list will change this week)

Oh and let me re-iterate that per my son all of these are better than anything since Capaldi.